JON CASIMIR, the Sydney Morning Herald's intellectual wafer-weight, thinks there isn't enough bias at the ABC. He writes: "Our national broadcaster should be run by Leon Trotsky to restore a sense of balance." Great start, Jon!
The ABC, as our leaders like to remind us, is a Petri dish choking with the bacteria of left-wing thought, the broadcasting equivalent of that coffee cup you find behind a pot plant when you come back from holidays.
Whoa! Slow down, awkward metaphor boy. Are you sure it's just our leaders who are saying this? Don’t you read letters pages? Submissions to parliament? Blogs?
Politicians bleat about balance, but what does that word mean in the context of this ongoing debate? Because it's one thing to provide balance according to the vacuum-sealed parameters of a particular program or a network, but what about the job of the ABC to provide balance in the broader sense?
What about it? Find me the section of the ABC’s charter that anoints it with a responsibility to balance any content other than its own.
I've always believed, no doubt naively …
No doubt.
… that the ABC should offer us an alternative to the programming of the commercial networks, in both radio and television. And if you look at the media landscape on that basis, any niggling sleights of left-wing bias seem pretty comical. In truth, the ABC would need to be three times the size and 300 per cent commie to provide anything approaching balance.
The assertion here that the non-ABC media represents a hotbed of conservative bomb-throwers is pretty hard to take. The vast mass of electronic media in Australia barely concerns itself with politics at any level. And Jon isn’t up to providing evidence or examples.
While reserving their right to complain about any expression of left-wing views, the conservatives somehow manage to overlook the fact that if the Australian media have a bottom-line skew, it isn't to the southpaw.
Maybe we'd complain less about left-wing views if the ABC ever presented anything from the right.
Oh, I forget; a few years ago the ABC did present a right-wing documentary series, Against Nature, that exposed deceitful environmentalists. The ABC – and this is the only time I can recall this happening, for anything presented by our state-funded dipshit broadcaster – ran a disclaimer stating that the "views in this program are those of its makers, and not necessarily those of the ABC."
Because this disclaimer doesn't run after every ABC appearance by Scott Burchill, Tariq Ali, or John Pilger, we may conclude that the ABC agrees with them.
You wouldn't, by any stretch of the imagination, refer to commercial television current affairs as leftist. Night after night it demonstrates contempt for society's vulnerable, picking on the weak, the disadvantaged and the voiceless.
Any examples, Jon? By the way, nice default method of defining leftists: they're the ones who don't demonstrate contempt for the weak. And why limit your examination of commercial television to the 30 minutes of current affairs presented each night by only two networks? Where's the rest of the satanic right-wing bigotry? Hidden in the clues on Wheel of Fortune?
Talkback radio is dominated by microphone jockeys, jacks of all tirades, who would rather make balloon animals out of their own intestines than allow a left-wing caller to make a point. (Phillip Adams is regularly namechecked by the anti-lefties, but try listing other Left hosts. Then see how quickly you can number the right-wingers.)
The main "right-wingers" to whom Jon alludes are John Laws and Alan Jones. Both are protectionists. Laws has sided with arch-protectionist leftie unionist Doug Cameron over trade barriers, and is a close friend of former Labor Prime Minister Paul Keating. The NSW Labor state government grovels to Jones. Jon Harker, Stan Zemanek, Steve Price and Neil Mitchell would probably also fall under Jon's right-wing description, although at least one has cast his vote for Labor in more than one election. There are other right-wing hosts in Adelaide, Brisbane, and Perth.
And here's that list of Left hosts you asked for:
Angela Catterns
Sally Loane
John Highfield
Eleanor Hall
James Valentine
Richard Glover
Sarah MacDonald
Virginia Trioli
Julie McCrossin
Mick O’Regan
Adam Spencer
Francis Leach
I could go on, but it's easier to just point readers towards the ABC website. Find a right-winger, win a prize.
The columnists of News Limited newspapers, organs which cater to about two-thirds of the national print market, unopposed in most of the state capitals, are not exactly known for their pinko views either, except for the above-mentioned "I am an island" Adams.
Plus Bruce Wilson, Jill Singer, Elizabeth Wynhausen, Graeme Leech, Bill Leak, Jonathan Este, Emma Tom …
And though the Herald is said to be another incubator of leftie weirdness, if you tally up our columnists according to their apparent allegiances and the regularity of their input, this paper is not so far from the centre.
Name the right-wingers, Jon! You’ve got Miranda Devine and Paul Sheehan each writing once a week (and Paddy McGuinness, now semi-retired, writing less frequently than that). But why restrict analysis of the Herald's right-wing content to the op-ed pages? Why not look at the general news pages, the sports pages, or even the stupid Herald television guide, featuring Doug Anderson and Bruce Elder?
If the Government is so interested in notions of fairness and debate, why doesn't it complain about right-wing bias outside the ABC? Is it because the rest of the media doesn't swallow taxpayers' money, or is it because it's conveniently "on message"?
Um, it's the tax thing, Jon. Obviously.
Jon Casimir is a Herald journalist.
Very obviously.